Audio Example 12.13:

"Hard Rain," live (1997, Portland; 1999, Ljubljana; 2000, Cincinnati; and 2001, Seattle)

Chapter 12
Audio Example 12.13
Page 302

"Hard Rain," live (1997, Portland; 1999, Ljubljana; 2000, Cincinnati; and 2001, Seattle)

Portland, ME; Ljubljana, Slovenia; Cincinnati, OH; Seattle, WA1997, 1999, 2000, 2001

Four performances from around the turn of the millennium show Dylan's evolving, post-Nara approach to the song. Note especially the restraint of the 2001 performance, his first rendition of the song after 9/11. There are no histrionics. Dylan does not overplay the song’s apocalyptic imagery or exaggerate the song-spanning build of tension, now standard from night to night. Instead, he offers a performance of comfort and determination.